Quick Comparision (Khandwala Securities VS 9Star Broking)

Khandwala Securities
Khandwala Securities Review gives an overall view and updates about the Brokerage Charges, Margin, Trading Software, Demat Account Charges, NRI Account, Branches, Customer Complaints

9Star Broking
9Star Broking Review gives an overall view and updates about the Brokerage Charges, Margin, Trading Software, Demat Account Charges, NRI Account, Branches, Customer Complaints

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Single Margin Facility	Yes
Year of Incorporation	1993	2004
Exchanges	NSE, BSE, MCX and NCDEX	NSE, BSE, MCX and NCDEX
Branches	794	128
Brokerage	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.04%
Broker Type	Full Service Broker	Full Service Broker

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Trading Account Opening Charge	Basic Plan - ₹0 (Free) \| Life Time Plan - ₹0 (Free)	₹0 (Free)
Demat Account Opening Charge	Basic Plan - ₹0 (Free) \| Life Time Plan - ₹0 (Free)	₹0 (Free)
Demat Account AMC	Basic Plan - ₹500 + GST per year (Individual) ₹1000 + GST per Year(Non-Individual) \| Life Time Plan - ₹1700 + GST per year (Individual) ₹5000 + GST per Year(Non-Individual)	Rs. 300 + Taxes for Individual (Yearly) Rs. 600 + Taxes for Non-Individual and Others (Yearly)
Trading Account AMC	N/A	N/A

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Commodity Futures	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.050 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.035 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.025 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 0.018 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.015 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 0.010	N/A
Currency Futures	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.050 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.035 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.025 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 0.018 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.015 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 0.010	0.04%
Equity Delivery	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.35%
Equity Options	Base Plan (NIL) - 50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 40 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 35 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 25 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 20 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 15	0.05% or upto ₹20
Commodity Options	Base Plan (NIL) - 50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 40 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 35 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 25 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 20 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 15	NA
Equity Futures	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.050 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.035 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.025 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 0.018 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.015 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 0.010	0.04%
Currency Options	Base Plan (NIL) - 50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 40 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 35 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 25 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 20 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 15	Rs.20 per Lot
Fixed Charges	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.04%
Equity Intraday	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.04%

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
RMS Square Off Charge	₹50 per order	₹20 per order
API Charges	Free API	₹0 (Free)
Call & Trade Charges	Rs. 50 (+ GST)	₹20 per order
Other Brokerage Charges	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.04%
Minimum Brokerage	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.04%

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Currency Options	Exchange txn charge: 0.035%	0.042%
Equity Futures	NSE: 0.0019%	NSE: 0.0019%
Equity Intraday	NSE: 0.00325% BSE: 0.00275%(BSE: charges vary as per the scrip group)	NSE: 0.00325% \| BSE: 0.003%
Equity Options	NSE: 0.05% (on premium)	NSE: 0.05%
Commodity	Group A Exchange txn charge: 0.0026% Group B Exchange txn charge: 0.006% Clearing charge: .00025%	Mcx: .0028% \| NCDEX: .006 % \| ICEX: .003%
Currency Futures	Exchange txn charge: 0.0009% Clearing charge: .00025%	0.0012%
Equity Delivery	NSE: 0.00325% BSE: 0.00275%(BSE: charges vary as per the scrip group)	BSE: 0.003% \| NSE: 0.00325%

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Equity Options	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (0% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))
Equity Intraday	5x (Up to 20% of trade value)	4x (Up to 20% of trade value)
Currency Options	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))
Commodity Options	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))
Commodity Futures	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))
Equity Delivery	1x (100% of trade value)	1x (100% of the trade value)
Currency Futures	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))
Equity Futures	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (0% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Online Portfolio
Algo Trading
Margin Trading Facility
Call & Trade Facility
Referral Program
Collateral Margin
Online Demo
3 in 1 Account
Charting
Intraday Square-off Time	Equity & F&O:- 3:30pm \| Currency: 4:45PM \| Commodities: 11:15 PM	Equity & F&O:- 3:20 PM \| Currency 4:20 PM \| Commodity:- 11:15 PM
Trading Platform	1.KSL EasyTrade Mobile App, 2. KSL EasyTrade Web Portal, 3. KSL Prive Desktop Software	1. 9Star Trader, 2. 9 Star Connect, 3. 9 Star Backoffice, 4.9 Star Wealth
SMS Alerts for Trades
Direct Mutual Fund

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Trading Brokerage
Customer Service
Fees
Trading Platform Usability
Mobile App
Research
Desktop Software
Overall Ratings
Broker Rating

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Currency
IPO
Commodity
Debt
Other Options
Stock Cash / Equity
Mutual Funds
Bond / NCD

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Bracket Order/BO/OCO
BTST
Cover Order/CO
Good Till Cancelled (GTC)
BUY ABOVE/SELL BELOW (SL-M)
After Market Order(AMO)
STBT

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Free Tips
Quarterly Result Analysis
Daily Market Report
News Alerts

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Daily Market Reports & News

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Casual Investor
Active Investor
Trader

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Pros	1.Wide Range of Financial Products 2.Research and Analysis, 3. Excellent customer service and support, 4. Collaborates with traditional institutions for hybrid solutions, 5. Competitive pricing and low fees. 6.User-Friendly Platform, 7. Competitive Pricing.	1.It charges low brokerage. 2.It provides the best trading terminal to its customers. 3.It provides education facility to its customers. 4.It avails its customers with refer and earn program. 5. Quick resolution of issues is crucial in the dynamic world of trading. 6. Diverse Investment Options.
Cons	1. Limited International Presence 2. Limited Advanced Features 3. Dependency on market conditions and economic factors, 4.Customer Service Concerns 5. Different fintech platforms may not seamlessly work together., 6. Restricted Investment Options.	1. High Minimum Investment Requirements 2. Limited control over market fluctuations 3. Complexity of investment options. 4. Customer Service Challenges. 5. Kedia Capital does not cover a broad spectrum of financial instruments or lacks certain investment options.

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Commodity Futures	0.01% on sell side (Non-Agri)	0.01% on the sell side
Currency Futures	No STT	No STT
Equity Intraday	0.025% on the sell side	0.025% on the sell side
Equity Options	0.0625% on sell side (on premium)	0.05% on the sell side
Currency Options	No STT	No STT
Equity Delivery	0.1% on buy & sell	0.1% on buy & sell
Equity Futures	0.0125% on sell side	0.01% on the sell side
Commodity Options	0.05% on sell side	0.05% on the sell side

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Equity Demat Transaction Charges	20 + GST per scrip	₹20 per request

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Equity/Currencies/Commodities ( Delivery & FNO)	18% on (Brokerage + Transaction Charge)	18% on (Brokerage + Transaction Charge)

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Equity/Currencies/Commodities ( Delivery & FNO)	₹10/Crore	₹10/Crore

Khandwala Securities

9Star Broking

Trading Account Opening Charge

Basic Plan - ₹0 (Free) | Life Time Plan - ₹0 (Free)

₹0 (Free)

Demat Account Opening Charge

Basic Plan - ₹0 (Free) | Life Time Plan - ₹0 (Free)

₹0 (Free)

Demat Account AMC

Basic Plan - ₹500 + GST per year (Individual) ₹1000 + GST per Year(Non-Individual) | Life Time Plan - ₹1700 + GST per year (Individual) ₹5000 + GST per Year(Non-Individual)

Rs. 300 + Taxes for Individual (Yearly) Rs. 600 + Taxes for Non-Individual and Others (Yearly)

Trading Account AMC

N/A

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
	Khandwala Securities Account Opening Process and Required Document Details Read more..	9Star Broking Account Opening Charges and Process Details Read more..

	Account Opening Demat Account Complaints Review Trading Software Mobile App Mutual Fund IPO Brokerage Exposure Branches NRI Account	Account Opening Demat Account Review Complaints Branches Mutual Fund Trading Software Mobile App IPO Exposure NRI Account Brokerage

9Star Broking
9Star Broking Review gives an overall view and updates about the Brokerage Charges, Margin, Trading Software, Demat Account Charges, NRI Account, Branches, Customer Complaints

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Commodity Futures	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.050 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.035 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.025 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 0.018 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.015 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 0.010	N/A
Currency Futures	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.050 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.035 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.025 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 0.018 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.015 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 0.010	0.04%
Equity Delivery	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.35%
Equity Options	Base Plan (NIL) - 50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 40 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 35 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 25 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 20 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 15	0.05% or upto ₹20
Commodity Options	Base Plan (NIL) - 50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 40 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 35 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 25 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 20 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 15	NA
Equity Futures	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.050 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.035 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.025 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 0.018 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.015 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 0.010	0.04%
Currency Options	Base Plan (NIL) - 50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 40 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 35 \| Option 3 (Rs.999) - 25 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 20 \| Option 5 (Rs.2999)- 15	Rs.20 per Lot
Fixed Charges	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.04%
Equity Intraday	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.04%

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Equity Options	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (0% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))
Equity Intraday	5x (Up to 20% of trade value)	4x (Up to 20% of trade value)
Currency Options	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))
Commodity Options	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))
Commodity Futures	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))
Equity Delivery	1x (100% of trade value)	1x (100% of the trade value)
Currency Futures	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))
Equity Futures	1x (100% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))	1x (0% of Normal margin (Span + Exposure))

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
RMS Square Off Charge	₹50 per order	₹20 per order
API Charges	Free API	₹0 (Free)
Call & Trade Charges	Rs. 50 (+ GST)	₹20 per order
Other Brokerage Charges	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.04%
Minimum Brokerage	Base Plan (NIL) - 0.50 \| Option 1 (Rs.249) - 0.35 \| Option 2 (Rs 499) - 0.25 \| Option 3 (Rs. 999) - 0.18 \| Option 4 (Rs.1999) - 0.15 \| Option 5 (Rs. 2999)- 0.10	0.04%

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Commodity Futures	0.01% on sell side (Non-Agri)	0.01% on the sell side
Currency Futures	No STT	No STT
Equity Intraday	0.025% on the sell side	0.025% on the sell side
Equity Options	0.0625% on sell side (on premium)	0.05% on the sell side
Currency Options	No STT	No STT
Equity Delivery	0.1% on buy & sell	0.1% on buy & sell
Equity Futures	0.0125% on sell side	0.01% on the sell side
Commodity Options	0.05% on sell side	0.05% on the sell side

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Equity Demat Transaction Charges	20 + GST per scrip	₹20 per request

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Equity/Currencies/Commodities ( Delivery & FNO)	18% on (Brokerage + Transaction Charge)	18% on (Brokerage + Transaction Charge)

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Equity/Currencies/Commodities ( Delivery & FNO)	₹10/Crore	₹10/Crore

	Khandwala Securities	9Star Broking
Online Portfolio
Algo Trading
Margin Trading Facility
Call & Trade Facility
Referral Program
Collateral Margin
Online Demo
3 in 1 Account
Charting
Intraday Square-off Time	Equity & F&O:- 3:30pm \| Currency: 4:45PM \| Commodities: 11:15 PM	Equity & F&O:- 3:20 PM \| Currency 4:20 PM \| Commodity:- 11:15 PM
Trading Platform	1.KSL EasyTrade Mobile App, 2. KSL EasyTrade Web Portal, 3. KSL Prive Desktop Software	1. 9Star Trader, 2. 9 Star Connect, 3. 9 Star Backoffice, 4.9 Star Wealth
SMS Alerts for Trades
Direct Mutual Fund

Zerodha

India's Largest Broker

Equity Delivery Free

Advanced Trading Platforms

Account Opening ₹200/-

Call Back Open Account

Alice Blue

Low Brokerage

FNO @ ₹15/Order

Free Trading Software

Free API Access

Call Back Open Account

Upstox

Free Account Opening

Flat ₹20 Brokerage

Free Technical Software

Backed by Ratan Tata Ji

Call Back Open Account

Angel One

Free Account Opening

Flat ₹20 Brokerage

Free Equity Delivery

Ultra-fast Digital Platform

Call Back Open Account

5Paisa

Various Brokerage Plans

Flat ₹20 Brokerage

Free Technical Software

Free Research Services

Call Back Open Account

Fyers

Free Equity Delivery

Intraday at ₹20/Order

Advanced Charting

Life Time Free AMC

Call Back Open Account

Stoxkart

No Profit No Brokerage

Free Equity Delivery

Brokerage of Flat ₹15/Trade

We earn only when you do

Call Back Open Account

ProfitMart

Free Account Opening

₹20/ Order

Free API Access

FREE Advanced Terminal

Call Back Open Account

Zebu Trade

Free Technical Software

Free API Access

Low Brokerage

Faster Payouts

Call Back Open Account

Flattrade

Free Account Opening

Decent Customer Services

Free Technical Software

Zero Brokerage in All Segments

Call Back Open Account

IIFL Securities

Free Research Reports

₹20/Order

₹0 AMC for 1st Year.

Free Research Services

Call Back Open Account

Kotak Securities

Various Types of Account

Free Account Opening

Flat ₹20/Order Brokerage

Zero Brokerage on Intraday

Call Back Open Account

ICICI Direct

Free Trading Account

Zero brokerage charges

Low Brokerage

Access to Award-winning research

Call Back Open Account

Sharekhan

International Presence

Free Account Opening

Open Account in Just 15 mins

Various Brokerage Slabs

Call Back Open Account

Paytm Money

Zero Account Opening

No Hidden Charges

Research Facility

Lowest Trading Charges

Call Back Open Account

Goodwill Commodities

₹11/ Order

Free Account Opening

Best Charting Software

Call Back Open Account

Groww

Growing Discount Broker

No Hidden Charges

No Transaction Charges in MF

₹20/ Order

Call Back Open Account

Samco

Growing Discount Broker

Free Account Opening

Instant Online Account

₹20/ Order

Call Back Open Account

Bajaj Finserve

Free Account Opening

Innovated Fixed Deposit

AMC Waived for 1 year

Free Advisory Services

Call Back Open Account

Finvasia

₹0 Brokerage on Trading

Free Account Opening

Commission Free Broker

Free Call & Trade

Call Back Open Account

SMC Global

International Presence

Competitive brokerage rates

Free Account Opening

Free Research Services

Call Back Open Account

FundsIndia

Free Investment Guidance

MF | Equities | F&O | NPS & more

Best in-Class Research

Free Account Opening

Call Back Open Account

mStock

Best Discount Broker

Margin Trading Facility

Advance Trading Platform

Provides Technical Analysis

Call Back Open Account

Rupeezy

Indian Stock Broker

Advance Trading Platform

Free Demat Account Opening

Call Back Open Account

GarvThakur.com

Quick Comparision (Khandwala Securities VS 9Star Broking)

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Broker Details

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Account Opening & AMC Charges

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Brokerage charges & Plans

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Other Charges

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Transaction Charges

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Margin (Exposure)

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Features

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Review & Rating

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Request a call back from Broker

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Investment Options

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Order Type

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Research & Report

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Daily Market Report

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Suitable For Investor

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Pros & Cons

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Background

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Compare All Brokers

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - STT/CTT

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Demat transaction charges

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - GST

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - SEBI Charges

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Account Opening & AMC Charges

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking

Khandwala Securities Account Opening Process and Required Document Details

9Star Broking Account Opening Charges and Process Details

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Brokerage charges & Plans

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Margin (Exposure)

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Other Charges

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - STT/CTT

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Demat transaction charges

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - GST

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - SEBI Charges

Khandwala Securities Vs 9Star Broking - Features

Khandwala Securities

9Star Broking