STOCK BROKER REVIEW | INVESTING | UPCOMING IPO | ALGO TRADING | TECHNICAL ANALYSIS

Comparision (SHORT GUTS VS PROTECTIVE PUT)

 

Compare Strategies

  SHORT GUTS PROTECTIVE PUT
About Strategy

Short Guts Option Strategy 

This strategy is implemented by a trader when he is neutral on the movements and bearish on volatility i.e. he expects the stock to be range bound in the near future. This strategy involves sale of 1 ITM Call Option and 1 ITM Put Option. This strategy can be called as Credit Spread since his account is credited at the time of entering in the positions.

Protective Put Option Strategy

Protective Put Strategy is a hedging strategy where trader guards himself from the downside risk. This strategy is adopted when a trader is long on the underlying asset but skeptical of the downside. He will buy one ATM Put Option to hedge his position. Now, if the underlying asset moves either up or down, the trader is in a safe position.

SHORT GUTS Vs PROTECTIVE PUT - Details

SHORT GUTS PROTECTIVE PUT
Market View Neutral Bullish
Type (CE/PE) CE (Call Option) + PE (Put Option) PE (Put Option)
Number Of Positions 2 1
Strategy Level Beginners Beginners
Reward Profile Limited Unlimited
Risk Profile Unlimited Limited
Breakeven Point Upper Breakeven Point = Net Premium Received + Strike Price of Short Call, Lower Breakeven Point = Strike Price of Short Put - Net Premium Received Purchase Price of Underlying + Premium Paid

SHORT GUTS Vs PROTECTIVE PUT - When & How to use ?

SHORT GUTS PROTECTIVE PUT
Market View Neutral Bullish
When to use? This strategy is implemented by a trader when he is neutral on the movements and bearish on volatility i.e. he expects the stock to be range bound in the near future. This strategy is adopted when a trader is long on the underlying asset but skeptical of the downside.
Action Sell 1 ITM Call, Sell 1 ITM Put Buy 1 ATM Put
Breakeven Point Upper Breakeven Point = Net Premium Received + Strike Price of Short Call, Lower Breakeven Point = Strike Price of Short Put - Net Premium Received Purchase Price of Underlying + Premium Paid

SHORT GUTS Vs PROTECTIVE PUT - Risk & Reward

SHORT GUTS PROTECTIVE PUT
Maximum Profit Scenario Net Premium Received + Strike Price of Short Put - Strike Price of Short Call - Commissions Paid Price of Underlying - Purchase Price of Underlying - Premium Paid
Maximum Loss Scenario Price of Underlying - Strike Price of Short Call - Net Premium Received OR Strike Price of Short Put - Price of Underlying - Net Premium Received + Commissions Paid Premium Paid + Purchase Price of Underlying - Put Strike + Commissions Paid
Risk Unlimited Limited
Reward Limited Unlimited

SHORT GUTS Vs PROTECTIVE PUT - Strategy Pros & Cons

SHORT GUTS PROTECTIVE PUT
Similar Strategies Short Strangle (Sell Strangle), Short Straddle (Sell Straddle) Long Call, Call Backspread
Disadvantage • Unlimited potential loss if the underlying stock continues to move in one direction. • High margin required. • Value of protective put position decreases as time passes • Holding period of the protective put can be affected by the timing as a result tax rate on the profit or loss from the stock can be affected.
Advantages • Ability to profit even when underlying asset stays stagnant. • You are already paid your full profit the moment the position is put on as this is a credit spread position. • Higher chance of ending in full profit as compared to short strangle or short straddle. • Unlimited potential profit due to indefinitely rise in the underlying stock price . • This strategy allows you to hold on to your stocks while insuring against losses. • Hedging strategy, trader can guard himself from the downside risk.

SHORT GUTS

PROTECTIVE PUT